Short answer

Common homepage problems include an unclear first screen, a random section order, confusing navigation, decorations that hinder reading and contact options hidden behind several steps. Check them on a phone and a computer, recording a specific symptom, location and acceptance criterion. A fault list alone does not prove falling sales: that conclusion requires data about users and enquiries.

1. The first screen sets a mood but does not explain the business

An office photo and “Creating the future together” could suit many businesses. Visitors still do not know whether they have found an accountant, a designer or an equipment manufacturer. Cover the logo and check whether the remaining content identifies the service and its audience. If answering requires scrolling through several screens, record an information-priority problem.

This does not mean adding the entire service catalogue to the headline. One specific sentence and a clear route to details are enough. For a ready-to-use editorial test, see the guide on writing a clear website offer. Here you are checking the wider homepage layout, not rewriting the entire offer again.

2. Every section appears equally important

News, company history, three promotions and a form can compete for attention on the same page. The problem is not the section count itself, but the unanswered question: what do visitors need first? List headings in order. They should form an understandable summary: what the business does, whom it helps, where to find details and how to start a conversation.

I suggest assigning one task to each section. If you cannot name it, consider moving the content to an appropriate page. This is an organisational recommendation, not a universal template. A business with several distinct audiences may need to offer a choice of paths before describing an individual service in detail.

3. The menu requires knowledge of the company’s language

“Possibilities”, “Inspiration” and “Our DNA” do not always explain what a click reveals. Give someone outside the business a specific task, such as finding the installation scope. Ask them to identify a menu item before opening it. Record incorrect choices without explaining the labels.

W3C WAI recommends clear, consistent navigation and easily identifiable interactive elements. In practice, similar buttons should have similar functions, and service names should not change between the menu and a page heading. Do not add another menu level simply because desktop space has run out; check how information is grouped first.

4. Photos and animation make the content hard to read

Text over a bright part of a photo, an automatic slider and background video can obscure rather than support the message. View every slide, not only the first. Check text readability, whether motion can be paused and whether important information disappears before it can be read. W3C describes contrast, media alternatives and control over automatically playing content as elements of accessible design.

A team or project photo makes sense when it genuinely shows the business and you have the right to publish it. Stock photography is not inherently wrong, but must not impersonate a specific customer, employee or completed project. Remove decoration only after deciding what information should replace it; an empty section does not solve the problem.

5. The mobile layout is a scaled-down desktop view

Open the website from the beginning on a narrow screen, without relying on knowledge of its layout. Check that navigation does not cover the logo, buttons stay within the screen and the consent panel does not block all content. Then enlarge the text and check that you can still read the offer and reach contact options. No horizontal scrolling is not enough: elements may overlap within the screen.

Test touch and keyboard use too. Something that looks like a button should behave as a button or link, and the currently focused element should be visible. This short review reveals faults, but is not a full WCAG compliance audit. Do not present it to customers as an accessibility certificate.

6. Contact options do not explain the next step

“Send” is not enough if visitors do not know what information to prepare or what the form concerns. Follow the journey from homepage to contact and record every step. Check that field labels, required information and error messages are visible. If a button opens a brief, do not call it an instant quote.

Agree a form-delivery test with the person handling the inbox and mark the message as a test. Do not assume that a website message confirms email delivery. Check the phone link and email address separately. Do not promise a response time unless the business has a process that can meet it.

7. A speed-test score replaces diagnosis

A website may seem ready yet still shift elements while loading or respond slowly. Web.dev distinguishes loading, interactivity and visual stability within Core Web Vitals. One score therefore does not describe the whole experience. Record the URL, device, date and specific symptom before commissioning “speed improvements everywhere”.

A laboratory result helps identify causes; real-user data offers a different perspective. Missing field data does not automatically mean good or bad performance. Do not compare a measurement on a fast computer with the experience of a customer using an older phone without explaining the difference.

An issue register: what to fix first

The order below is the author’s aid for organising work, not the result of testing your website. Start with blocked actions, resolve misunderstandings next and assess decoration last. Each item needs an owner and an acceptance test.

SymptomFirst fixAcceptance criterion
Contact cannot be openedRepair the link or blocking layerThe user reaches the correct form
It is unclear what the business doesClarify the first screenSomeone outside the business correctly identifies the service
The menu forces visitors to guessImprove labels and groupingThe task can be completed without hints
Text is obscured on a phoneFix the layout and overlapping elementsContent and buttons remain accessible

How to finish the review without commissioning everything again

Record the three most important faults and add a screenshot, URL and reproduction steps for each. Separate facts, such as a broken link, from hypotheses, such as “this photo reduces enquiries”. A hypothesis needs research or data, not a designer’s opinion alone. After fixes, repeat the same tasks on the same pages.

This review covers the homepage and does not replace a whole-site audit, migration plan or integration analysis. Google recommends content created for users; adding sections solely for keywords is not the goal. Once the main journey works, decide whether a broader upgrade is needed.

Sources and scope of recommendations

The issue register and review order are practical recommendations, not a promise of increased sales, Google rankings or visibility in AI answers.

Planning improvements or a new website?

In the brief, describe the current URL and the most important faults. This is a starting point for agreeing scope, not an automatic quote or a full audit.

Open the website brief (in Polish) ↗