Short answer

Before spending money, check whether the website leads towards a specific goal, explains the offering clearly, works on a phone, is accessible to crawlers and people, and whether decisions are based on evidence. An audit should distinguish a confirmed fault from a hypothesis that requires data.

First, establish what the website is supposed to achieve

You cannot assess a website fairly without a goal. For one business, that will be submitting a form; for another, a phone call, booking an appointment, selling a product or downloading a proposal. Write down one primary step and no more than two supporting ones. Only then can you check whether the headline, content, CTA and form guide the visitor in the same direction.

For example, if the goal is a service enquiry, the website does not need to explain the company's entire history before showing a way to get in touch. However, it should adequately answer these questions: what do you offer, for whom, what problem do you solve, what happens after contact, and why should the visitor trust this information?

Do not buy a “score”; buy evidence

It helps to separate three levels in an audit. A fact is something reproducible: a URL returns 404, a button points to the wrong section, horizontal scrolling appears at 390 px, or a page has noindex. A conclusion connects a fact with a risk; for example, the lack of a visible CTA may make it harder to initiate contact. A hypothesis needs additional data, such as “users abandon the form because the fields are too long”. Do not present a hypothesis as the cause without session recordings, analytics or a controlled test.

This distinction protects your budget. It lets you remove real, verifiable obstacles first, rather than rebuilding an element just because someone thinks it is “outdated”.

A practical audit checklist

AreaWhat to checkEvidence to expect
Goal and offeringDoes the first screen explain what the company does and for whom?A screen capture and a quotation of the visible headline and CTA.
Contact journeyDo buttons, phone numbers, email links and forms have the correct destinations?A list of links and statuses, and a safe form validation test.
MobileDo the menu, text, fields and CTAs fit at a width of 390 px?A screenshot and a check for horizontal overflow.
IndexingDoes an important page return 200, have a canonical and have no noindex directive?The raw HTTP response and the values of meta robots and canonical.
ContentIs the answer specific and consistent with the offering?A comparison of the H1, headings, price/terms and visible CTA.
MeasurementDo you know which sources and actions lead to contact?A description of events and analytics gaps; no conclusions based on page views alone.

Look at the offering through a first-time visitor's eyes

Open the website in a new session, without relying on prior knowledge of the company. Within a dozen or so seconds, try to answer: what does the company do, who is the offering for, what distinguishes it from an alternative, and what is the next step? If the answer depends on extensive scrolling, vague slogans or guesswork, that is a communication problem — even if the visual design looks fine.

Check consistency too. The service name, scope, claims and terms in the hero, service pages, FAQ and contact section should not contradict each other. An audit does not replace legal advice, but it can identify an unclear or inaccessible promise, price footnote or link to terms and conditions.

Mobile and basic UX: test a scenario, not just a view

On a phone, one screenshot at the top of the page is not enough. Follow a CTA from a lower section, open the navigation, try to return to the contact section and check the form fields. It is worth viewing the site at a width of 390 px, where protruding elements, tiny text, obscured buttons and horizontal scrolling are easiest to notice.

Do not submit a real form just to “tick off” a test. Without authorisation, you can check client-side validation, required fields and links. Message delivery requires a separate, controlled test and confirmation in the specified inbox.

SEO: the minimum that must be verifiable

An important page should be publicly accessible and return HTTP 200. Google states that, for a page to be eligible for indexing, Googlebot must not be blocked and the content must be indexable. The robots.txt file alone is not a way to hide a page from search results — exclusion requires noindex while allowing crawling, or access protection.

For each important page, record: the final URL after redirects, status, title, meta description, one H1, canonical, meta robots and visible internal links. A sitemap should contain preferred canonical URLs, and lastmod should reflect a significant change. This does not guarantee indexing or rankings, but it provides a technical starting point for further diagnosis.

How to prioritise the work

  1. Remove blockers: broken key links, 404 errors, noindex on an important page, missing contact options and unusable mobile layouts.
  2. Resolve ambiguities: an offering without a defined audience, a CTA that does not explain the next step, contradictory information and hidden terms.
  3. Fill measurement gaps: define the primary conversion and check whether it can be distinguished from an ordinary visit.
  4. Only then expand: new content, larger sections, experiments and more extensive modernisation.

This approach does not promise growth after one change. It helps reduce the risk of spending your budget on an outcome that cannot later be linked to the problem or verified.

What the audit handover should include

Ask for a list of URLs and screens covered, priorities, reproducible evidence and an explanation of how each fix will be verified. A good recommendation includes a location, observation, impact and specific acceptance test. “Improve SEO” does not meet that standard. “On /usluga/, the canonical points to another address; set it to the intended URL and check the page source again” does.

Google's official materials emphasise accessible, indexable content, an organised technical structure and structured data that matches visible content. That is a better starting point than a collection of shortcuts or guarantees of results.

Sources

Want to start with verifiable signals?

GEO Check analyses publicly accessible website elements and shows evidence and a prioritised action plan — without promising rankings or citations.

Check your website with GEO Check ↗